In this context, it is difficult to visit the museum simply as a way of honoring the dead and learning their stories. But there are likely other reasons, too. People also ask Weinstein how she could work at the museum every day, but she comes in only once a week. We were in it together, we were compassionate with one another, we hugged strangers on the street, people volunteered for public service, she said, adding, It was far too short-lived. I asked whether it couldnt also be said that 9/11 had brought out the worst in us, given that it was used to justify acts of violence, torture, and discrimination. List by Sept11PMFund. Reached recently by phone, Shulan told me that he was turned into the title character of the movie without his knowledge, and that, while he had real disagreements with his colleagues, the tone of those conflicts had been mischaracterized. (The handle of the squeegee is displayed in a glass box.) This is how we are united together. Greenwald, for her part, said that the filmmakers do not seem to understand that everything we do here must honor the commemorative nature of the site. The victims' inscriptions appear to be carved in gold. Wall Street and the New York Stock Exchange anchor New York City's Financial District, and the famed Brooklyn Bridge, one of the country's oldest and most scenic roadway bridges, spans the East River to connect the boroughs of Manhattan and Brooklyn. The 9/11 Memorial includes the names of the nearly 3,000 victims ofthe 2001 terrorist attack on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. waymarking cass libbie waymark View > Zoom InMacintosh Shortcut: Command+. After the legendarily competitive Lowell High School dropped selective admissions, new challengesand new opportunitiesarose. There was a ceremony for victims' families followed by an official opening for the general public the next day. We look at that legacy, too.. And I can remember even thinking what happens if 10-15 years from now people are driving by the Pentagon and they don't remember what side got hit because you know, life goes on, Laycheck told WAVY. Steven Rosenbaum, a co-director of The Outsider, suggested that, if nothing else, the movie, which has been widely reviewed, has given people permission to be more critical about sentimental portrayals of September 11th. It opened in 2008, but unlike the memorials in New York and Pennsylvania, it has no education center. She tells the story of Jan Demczur, a window washer caught in an elevator above the fiftieth floor with five other passengers, who used the metal handle of his squeegee to pry open the elevator doors, punch a hole through the Sheetrock, and lead them to escape. Explanatory blocks of text were stylized to look like redacted government documents. When Weinsteins legs began to cramp, and she stopped to rest, a stranger asked whether she needed assistance.

Afterward, I asked her about her experience on the job. View > Zoom > Zoom In, In the View menu, select Text Size. In 1993, Myrna Weinstein worked on the sixty-first floor of the north tower of the World Trade Center as a corporate trainer in the human-resources department of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. They seem to prefer a museum that is critical of U.S. foreign policy with less emphasis on what happened here. Greenwald used to work at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum, and she told me that one challenge with the 9/11 Museum was that it was built and designed before the event had passed from memory to historya moment it is reaching only now, she said. Hennes had hoped that the museum might broach some of the political implications of the day in a section of the historical exhibition called Aftermath. A proposal for a montage of politicians using the site for political ends was dropped in favor of a video about the recovery workersa legitimate choice, Hennes said, but one that hides a troubling legacy of the event. Who are we as a nation? Menu > Zoom > +, In the View menu, select Zoom. We looked at the posters of the missing that hung in the streets of lower Manhattan. Weinstein retired from the Port Authority in 2002. Pentagon Memorial Fund Executive Director Jim Laycheck's brother, Dave, did not make it out. A wall-sized mosaic of squares in shades of blue, by the artist Spencer Finch, features one square for every person who died in the attacks in 1993 and on September 11th, Weinstein explained, adding that the blues attempt to evoke the shade of the sky on the latter day. Discover Manhattan's Long & Curious Past on Guided Tours, The 10 Tallest Buildings in New York City. T-shirts are sold alongside mugs and keychains that bear the words Never Forget. (The museum has received government grants but is private, and relies on ticket sales and donations to stay afloat.) I had just come off active duty the week before, that morning I had gone to the Pentagon gym, he said. Get more information about the Reflection Room. The memorial aboveground, with its falling waters and dark pools, where flowers are placed in the grooves of the names of the dead on their birthdays, is perhaps better suited to mourning. They are both located at the World Trade Center site. If you would like to donate, click here. Most browsers include functionality to let you increase or decrease the text on a web page. At an intersection nearby, she saw an object that looked like an engine cordoned off by yellow police tape. September 11th as an inflection point that reordered world politics and ushered in a new phase of American civic life is not seriously considered. Her mother used to tell her that the event wouldnt define them. She stopped going to the high floors of tall buildings.

The video has never been changed. The 9/11 Memorial Museum commemorates the lives of every victim of the 2001 and 1993 attacks, sharing the story of 9/11 through exhibitions including artifacts and various multimedia displays. On September 11th, at 8:46 A.M., she was walking toward the elevators to see whether the classrooms on the seventy-eighth floor were ready for her when a plane struck more than fifteen stories above.

By 2001, she had been promoted. Ad Choices. One of the panel members, Sheikh Mostafa Elazabawy, an imam at Masjid Manhattan, resigned from the panel in protest. Famous chefs and restaurateurs such as Daniel Boulud, Wolfgang Puck, and Danny Meyeroperate locations in lower Manhattan, where you can also find city stalwarts such as Delmonico's, P.J. When Miller went to college, she decided to study Middle Eastern history and Arabic, with a focus on Osama bin Laden. For example, to increase text size using: In the menu to the right of the address bar, select and set Zoom level. View > Text Size > Largest, In the View menu, select Zoom In. She saw it as a message from God, telling her to be grateful. One of the ways we do truly honor those who have sacrificed is to try and make meaning of that sacrifice, not just in a rearward-looking direction, Tom Hennes told me. Outside, it was a snowy day. We reached the historical exhibition, which recounts the attacks minute by minute, with small breakaway areas that document the planes that crashed into the Pentagon and in Shanksville. She is also a travel agent and NYC & Company-certified New York City specialist. 2022 All Rights Reserved.

He believes that New Yorkers are attracted to complexity, and that the museum is the opposite of that. Its simplistic, its Islamophobic, its racist, its a whole series of things that anybody who goes there feels, he said. Common browsers are included in this page; mention of a specific browser does not imply endorsement or recommendation. She didnt know whether she was descending into a fire or whether she would be overcome with smoke inhalation. Photographs by Tonje Thilesen for The New Yorker. Weinstein excels at sharing accounts of resilience, altruism, and luck. All rights reserved. We visited a special exhibition on the killing and capture of Osama bin Laden, a supplement to a display of artifacts in the museums permanent collection, which includes a brick from the complex where bin Laden had hidden, in Pakistanwhich was brought to the U.S. by a reporter for Fox Newsand a shirt worn by a member of the Navy SEAL Team 6, which carried out the assassination. In the years after the attacks, New Yorkers saw their citys tragedy used to justify discrimination against Muslims, and also mass surveillance, torture, secret prisons, and two wars, in which hundreds of thousands of people were killed. On her first visit, Weinstein could smell a faint mustiness, and the odor, combined with the images and sounds of the exhibitsthe recorded voices of panic and the clanking alarms of the first respondersassaulted her senses. Weinstein thinks that locals are reluctant to visit because the event is still too raw for them. She argued that the museums live programming has a much broader focus than the exhibitions themselves. Here, you can see a two-story building design, Ep: He was on his way to the Navy Command Center, which is right where the plane hit, but checked the time and ran out to a meeting instead. On a recording, the names of the dead are read out loud, as they are at the memorial on each anniversary. She reached her brothers office, and stayed there until 11:30 A.M., by which time both towers had collapsed. We looked at the damaged commemorative plaque of the 1993 attack and a crushed fire truck from Ladder Three, a station in the East Village that lost twelve firefighters, plus a captain and a lieutenant. An education center, these men say, could put it in perspective. How an Ivy League School Turned Against a Student. Weinstein hopes that someday there will see an exhibition dedicated to the civilians who helped on September 11th and in the weeks that followedincluding the construction workers, many of them undocumented immigrants, who did much of the cleanup, some of whom have suffered health complications in the intervening years. (She recalled a rejected proposal for an exhibition about Little Syria, the community of Arabic-speaking Christian immigrants from the Middle East who, in the nineteenth century, settled in the neighborhood later occupied by the World Trade Center.) Her almost forensic understanding of the temperature of the fires in the building and how those fires affected the buildings steel frame speaks to the persistence of outlandish theories about what brought the towers down. york museum memorial newyorkcity tickets newyork